Home Port - CHILMARK

Excellent experience. Perfectly cooked lobster. Best place to start your trip on the vineyard.

We were a party of 6. Waited to be seated even though they were not crowded. Obviously short staffed. They close for the season next week. Was told there was no more lobsters scallops or swordfish. The 3 best items on their menu. Extremely disappointing. Portion sizes soooo small. Not reflective of the prefixed dinner of $79. Went home hungry. Pictures say it all.

Excellent food for a great price. $79 includes an appetizer, entree, and a dessert. There are also a few bread options to start and also raw bar add ons available. You are able to see the ocean and the sunset from the outside porch. The service was incredible. Our waiter was so friendly and very knowledgeable with the menu and was able to answer all of our questions. Don't forget, this is a BYOB establishment.

My husband and I visited this restaurant after exploring Menemsha while staying at the Menemsha Inn for a wedding. The food was excellent (the scallops were perfectly seared with just the right amount of char), the service was prompt and friendly, and the views were stunning. In addition, the manager, Max, went above and beyond by offering us a ride back to the inn when it started raining. She truly went the extra mile, and our dining experience was flawless. I would highly recommend this restaurant!

Nice place if you have patio reserved seating around 730pm. Service was good. Food was not worth the price. It's a fixed price menu. $79 for appetizer, entree dessert per person. Oysters, shrimp, etc would be an additional cost outside of what's listed as an appetizer. Food presentation was nice, however it lacked flavor. Miso blue fish has a sweet sauce on top but it did not pair well with a smoky dry quinoa on a bed of bok choy. Salmon was also dry but it was paired with a watermelon radish, butter beans and cucumber salad which was good. IMPORTANT. This area is a DRY TOWN. So you MUST BYOB if you want alcohol with your meal. Suggest you bring at least 2 bottles for 3 or more people. Otherwise, it is strictly water (still, sparkling or tap) and soda only. View is decent while eating since it sits near shallow water. But I would forego the $200+ bill and just order the local Menemsha oysters dessert with the wine you carried in just for the experience.