The Bagelry - Cedar Knolls

They need a lot of improvement. I've been here twice on my lunch break. Both times I've ordered a sausage egg and cheddar on a wrap and it was wrong. First time they missed the cheese. Second time they put it on a roll when I paid for a wrap. And does a wrap come with sesame seeds? Also I ordered cheddar cheese looks like for a second time no cheese but was definitely charged for it. I guess that's what happens when you have 13 yr old cashiers and 17 yr old cooks. Won't be coming back. This is a simple order and they can't get it correct. I wonder how they manage large orders. I have no idea how they have such a high rating, this simple order took 25mins to make.

Decent spot to check out, got a few bagels along with our bagel sandwiches. Wouldn?t say they were the best, but they weren?t bad either. Do not get the coffee though, that was awful.

This was our favorite bagel spot near Morristown bagel and cream cheese selection is great. Unfortunately, they can?t keep up with orders. After waiting 40+ mins for 2 egg cheese bagels during my past few visits, I have to say goodbye. The Jury Box has yet to let us down. Definitely recommend stopping there instead.

Stopped in on a Friday morning to grab a taylor ham, egg and cheese and it took 20 minutes to get my sandwich. They were busy but not crazy busy. It's a Friday and people need to get to work. If it's going to take 20 minutes, at least have the courtesy to warn me there's a backup when I'm ordering so I can decide whether or not to wait. Once I've paid, I'm stuck.

This place is the absolute worst. They never answer the phone (on a phone system that has been supposedly getting fixed for 2 years now). 9 out of the 10 times the order is wrong despite reading the order back and confirming it 3 times. COMPLETELY OVER PRICED. Imagine paying $14, after tax, for ham and Swiss on a croissant!!! Unbelievable. Legit the last time I order from the establishment. I try to support local but it?s hard to when they haven?t had a single order right over the past two years (8-10 orders).