Nick's Pizza - Castle Shannon

Update: new owners have done a great job. The pizza and wings are excellent, and everything else we have tried is solid. They also deliver on time and offer reliable service, which is more than we can say for the other place over on Castle Shannon.

We've enjoyed Nick's Pizza over the last few years and have mostly had good experiences but our order last night was underwhelming. Maybe it was because we ordered it to be ready at a future time (1 hr) and they made it early and it was sitting for a while. But the pizza was just warm, the toppings were sparse and the wings were overcooked but just warm and not as crispy (since they were sitting in the box steaming for a while). Disappointing experience and probably won't be back for a while. It wasn't our usual experience so maybe it's just a one off but we'll be sticking with our other favorites in the area going forward.

Surprised by the great pizza and hoagies here. Nice staff.

Great pie, friendly people. Owner is super cool. Makes a point to say hi to me everytime.

Really good pizza for a pretty reasonable price. Only downfall is that they didn't offer delivery to our home but otherwise, everything was great!