Dough Arrows Carlisle Edible Cookie Dough Ice Cream

This place was SOOOOOOO GOOD! DEF TRY the peanut butter brownie with cookie dough icecream! Great combo! My littles had peanut butter jimmy w mint choc chip icecream and she loved it! We’re coming again soon! Thank you for the kind hospitality!

Meh. Chocolate chip cookie dough had no real flavor. Just bland cookie dough with a play dough type aftertaste and chocolate chips. Very underwhelming. The whole place smelled like beer. Maybe it was a drinking establishment previously. Wouldn’t go again.

At the Hummelstown Food Truck Festival we ordered what we thought was ice cream and got some kind of warm gritty dough. After few bites we threw it away. It was disgusting and not at all refreshing on a hot humid day.

I was so excited to try this place. I walked by it several times but each time it was closed. When I finally saw it was open I had to try it. Loved how there were games on the tables. It was a bummer that they only had half of their ice cream out and they were out of a lot of other things. Seems like the store has a lot of potential but I was slightly disappointed.

My fiancé ordered a custom order $50 cheesecake on Monday to surprise me for my birthday on Friday. Got the confirm email to pick up Friday at 3:30pm. We drove 40 minutes to get it doors were locked. We went over to redds and ate and at 4:30 still locked with signs on saying opened. We waited a few more minutes and left. Super super disappointed.