Mayer's Tavern - CAPE MAY

We had a fantastic evening at this welcoming restaurant that feels like a cozy pub, with a focus on fresh food! We enjoyed the concise menu that offers something for every taste, all beautifully presented and tasty. Our server Kelly was fantastic. We waited until the busy rush died down and can't wait to come back soon. This place is a hidden gem in Cape May, with everything being fresh and delicious - you won't be disappointed!

This place is a bit of a dive bar with live music, but the food is pretty good. The inside dining area is small with seating at the bar, and there is also outside patio dining. We chose to sit inside, and the service was fine, but not very enthusiastic. We started with drinks and the crab fritters, which were pretty good, especially with the sauce. The cold front cocktail was excellent, but my wife didn't care for the hibiscus drink. The menu is limited, so we both went with the fried scallops that came with tasty french fries and vinegary coleslaw. The scallops had very little breading, but were flavorful and came with your choice of sauce.

I have never had any problems with the food at this restaurant, but the service and policies have been issues in the past. I visited on April 19th and everything was fantastic. I still think about that Cold Front dish!

Lovely casual spot. Excellent scallops. Pleasant staff. Nice outdoor seating. Highly recommended

Pretty solid food! Amazing scallops. Bartenders were nice and the service was very good. Had a great seat near the corner of the bar so we had an easy time talking with each other. Cozy little spot!