Shy Guy Gelato - Burlington

Dark chocolate gelato was really amazing. friendly service with reasonable trips. must try!

Not sure what is up with people, but when we got to the Shy Guy Gelato store, there was a queue of about 15 people winding from the window counter of the store to the sidewalk. This was at 15 mins before their closing time on a Wednesday. We went in with high hopes looking at the reviews and of course the long line of Gelato lovers. Sadly, our hopes and expectations were met. The Gelato itself was meh. The quality was not even close to a standard run of the mill Ben and Jerry's ice cream. The quantity was less compared to the price. It think it is just an over hyped place. You can find lots of way better ice cream places in Vermont.

Paul is the absolute best and such a talent! We have long been shy guy fans, but we hired them for our wedding welcome party and as always they brought the best gelato and our guests were raving about how good it was. Always worth stopping in for a cup, but even more fun to have them for your event!

Phenomenal gelato! I love that they do small batch flavors that change on a daily basis. Some of my favorite flavors are hazelnut, black forest cake and peanut butter crunch. I also love that they now have a frequent buyer punch card (get a free small with every 9 purchases).

Best gelato ever?? we got all 6 flavors available in two medium sized cups. our faves were pumpkin spice, greek yogurt and raspberry sorbet. must try when you’re in burlington.