My Tomato Pie - Buffalo

Very good food. Service good. We were at a private party. It was nice.

A cute little restaurant with wonderful servers! Highly recommend!

I was here for a luncheon and the food was awesome. If you have issues with food due to allergies they will accommodate so I would definitely recommend this place. Great staff as well.

The food is good, notably for a Pie shop. It's a comfortable spot to sit down with Fam or even have a drink with crew. Tomato Pie isn't overkill with TVs at the Bar, but tasteful... For me, what sets this place apart from others is that Peg, our Server (on 3 occasions) has been nothing short of outstanding. She understands our needs. Being that we have a toddler, she's mindful and attentive, even when it's busy! Also, the Manager comes out and makes sure everyone is doing well which is something you don't see much of these days. There's plenty of spots serving up proper Italian and Pizza in WNY, but this one does it better than most in my opinion.

Food was good. Sad they took the fried tomatoes off the menu. We came in around 7 and we felt very rushed by some of the servers even though they didn’t close until 10pm. The server who took our order seemed very attentive at first but he proceeded to approach our table numerous times after we said we wouldn’t need anything else for awhile. After this, he sent another server over to our table who also rushed us the whole time… She brought the check over before we were even done eating. She then started to take all the condiments off the table and started sweeping the floor right by our table as if that was supposed to be our que to get up and leave. She kept pacing back and forth by our table and staring as if we were inconveniencing her by still being there. It just wasn’t a good feeling being rushed by these servers and I don’t think we’ll be back. Probably will just order take out from this place from now on to avoid certain servers from breathing down our backs every 10 minutes just because they want to clean the table off. Like I understand wanting to get off of your shift but it’s completely unreasonable to rush people when they come in hours before the closing time. Ridiculous!!!!