Hearth Press - Buffalo

Would you like some food with your salt? After sharing a small pizza with my husband, I left feeling like my heart was racing. We had to drink several glasses of water just to wash down all that salt. However, there are two redeeming qualities: the location is pretty fantastic, and I enjoyed the shuffleboard.

The restaurant is conveniently located near the theaters. However, the menu was not as extensive as we had anticipated, and when we inquired about off-menu cocktails, we were informed that only the specials were available, despite the bar appearing to be well-stocked. The food was good, but the service was slow, and we were asked to leave just as we were finishing our meal to make room for other patrons. This made us feel rushed and somewhat poorly attended to. Despite these issues, we would consider returning.

This is a fantastic spot in downtown! I really enjoyed the selection of artisan pizzas, and the stuffed peppers were absolutely delicious—I would definitely return just for those. The Za'atar pizza is a must-try as well. However, I do have one critique: the pizza could use more cheese. The Margherita pizza we ordered had a lot of sauce but not enough cheese.

Best pizza in Buffalo. Solid service. Cool atmosphere and location, with views of Shea?s. A favorite spot before a movie as well.

Hearth Press is a go-to for me every time I'm on Main or headed to Town Ballroom. This pizza is cooked to perfection! Dough-y, but the crust is crispy and they're very careful not to over-cook. The pepperoni is slightly charred, giving it a really nicetexture. I know that you can share the pizzas, but I don't think I could do that. Just too good! Quick service and friendlystaff. This place is a must in Buffalo.