Brennan And Carr - Brooklyn

The Roast beef roll was absolutely incredible and well worth the journey from Manhattan. Staff were very nice and I even enjoyed the ice cold bud.

First of all, this is a wonderful local gem in South Brooklyn. My boyfriend and I have been here several times and every single time we've loved it. Wait times deserve a 10/10, the food is wonderful, he gets the gargiulo burger every visit and every time he raves about it. We almost always get the same set of appetizers and they're always phenomenal (corn fritters, onion rings, and mozzarella sticks). I've also gotten the clam chowder a few times, and the chicken tenders both deserve a 9/10. The atmosphere is great, it feels small town and cozy, and you can feel the love that radiates in that place. Best of all, and the star of the place is the staff. Every time we've been we've had the pleasure of having a brother duo as our servers (whose names I always forget to ask). They're helpful, attentive, quick on their feet, and personable, 11/10 for the wait staff. Truly a really wonderful place and next to a million times better than Roll N' Roster. If you're debating checking this place out, do it.

I don't like roast beef but I enjoyed the roast beef from here. They soak it in a delicious beef broth or u can get the broth on the side for dipping or u can do what I did and get both. I got the gargulio burger which was juicy and flavorful. The fries were ok, the onion rings and chicken wings were good. The best things by far tho were the dessert and the service. The dessert was a hot slice of blueberry pie( they also have apple) with two scoops of vanilla ice cream. The waiter was friendly and helpful. Even tho we accidentally stayed past closing he didn't rush us to leave.

Love Brennan and Carr. Roast beef is the best anywhere. The gargiulo burger is outrageous. Brennan and Carr is a must go for the roast beef but the gargiulo burger is the only burger I will eat anywhere outside of my home. This is old School NYC.

The roast beef au jus and onion rings are my go to. I have loved it since the first time I visited years ago. Everything on the menu is delicious but these are my favs!