Nonno Lorenzo's Pizza - Branchville

What can I say? It is convinient pizza place with reasonable prices. Many rural pizza places have no specific decor and it is very simple inside. This pizza place just like that, nothing unique, plain. Also, many rural pizza places have simple selection- mostly greasy, cheesy, meaty pies. Nothing fancy. But I wish for something unique! Margarita, vegetables, salad pizza! I want pizza and I want it somewhat healthy and delish at the same time. I love salad pizza from Pizza 1 in Sparta. Its not only people from NY who want uniqueness. That is the only thing I am going to say. I saw some broccoli and mushrooms and I was happy with this place. Thank you. By the way, we stayed in Cobmin Ridge Motel nearby. Beautiful rooms. Very cozy. Great area for hiking. But its lucking cool places to eat and drink coffee.

I liked the food in the institution, next time I will definitely order their specialty.

I had to post my positive experience here after reading a few negative reviews. We ordered a cheese calzone for dinner tonight. It was definitely a family size and it was DELICIOUS. We have ordered from the new owners a few times now and we have no complaints. I thought the owner was very nice. I hope people give them a try.

Never again! Second time ordering from here. First time was amazing this time, horrible. Ordered our food for pick up, got home and realized our food was wrong I know should have checked there but we only live down the road). We called to let them know, and were willing to bring back. The owner very rudely said we got what we paid for and proceeded to call my brother in law an “f-ing idiot”. This place is a real class act!

Last time I 'll Order Here! New owner has really let this place go downhill. An hour and a half for our order tonight and once again, the food was mediocre. The Italian sub... I can get better at Quick Chek and Jersey Mike 's. The sub roll seemed processed, not fresh. The meat was cut so thick and was watery. Barely any lettuce and hardly any oil and vinegar. Lasagna was OK. Meatball sub...meatballs seemed processed too. Chicken salad was OK, but not for the price. Garlic knots... half raw and I couldn 't taste any garlic. SO disappointing, especially after waiting for so long. We 've had pizza here before as well. You can find much better elsewhere in Sussex county. My recommendation: Keep looking.