Benny's Italian Eatery

I love Bennys! I'm not going anywhere. GENERAL I have ordered in the last 8 years is delicious. I'm a long time, quite frequent customer and I have nothing bad to say about Bennys. Everyone is very friendly, the food is AMAZING and the prices are very reasonable. I'll give an order as soon as I post it.

We tried the small calzones and found them to be delicious. Each calzone was large enough to share between two people. They were also prepared quickly.

I never expected to find the best traditional pizza in the small town of Boiling Springs, PA. The dough recipe is spot on, earning this pizzeria a perfect 5-star rating. This cozy little restaurant will exceed your expectations. Bravo, Benny's. Bravo.

I was pleasantly surprised to find a restaurant open on New Year's Eve, and I stumbled upon a real gem! The old school Veggie Pizza was absolutely incredible! The combination of spices and fresh veggies made my mouth water with every bite. And when Guy Fieri visited, it was truly a WOW moment!

This was our first time dining at Benny's, and we will definitely be returning! The pizza was incredible, especially the crust.