Butter Maid Bakery - Boardman

My father in-law started talking about “nut rolls” his mom made when he was kid. He couldn’t find an Eastern European bakery. So I googled, and look what was found! We bought 2 for Christmas and since reordered. He said these were the best he has ever had!

Butter Maid Bakery's Nut Kolachi Cookies are true blue favorites! My father's grandmother used to make them when he was a kid. In his younger years he made these at our family home. When I saw them, I knew I had to send them to him for Father's Day. He was so surprised pleased! Dad said they were just like his grandmother's! A compliment not to be taken lightly.I knew if dad liked them so would my father in law, here's 102! He enjoyed them as well. Said they were the softest cookie he's ever had.The pastry is light, fluffy sweet. The Nut mixture is savory. these cookies are great with coffee, and brought many good memories to my family. A true winner!

My first order of the all nut Kolachi was delicious. I am still waiting to try my poppy seed. I just ordered 3 different kinds to keep in the freezer. I hope they are all as good as the first. I just saw a bad review that their cakes arrived stale and dry. Oh no! I hope not.

Tried the pecan kolochi, the crust was pinched on one side and torn on the other. This should not have made it past QC. However the flavor was delicious.

I've been ordering from them for a few years, but this year they really went above and beyond! First off, their kolache is delicious. But, this year I accidentally inverted some numbers on the delivery address and didn't realize it. They sent a new order to the correct address after we both figured out why it wasn't delivered! Talk about going above and beyond!! Die hard fan for life now.