New York City Pizza - Bluffton

Charge $24 for 2 slices of Supreme style pizza. They just put raw veggies on a slice of pre made pepperoni. They did not cook them .Confronted manager she said that was the price told her it was bad did not offer discount. Place is over priced little Ceasars quality. I am a chef also

Once again, my friend Rob (owner) has a great pizzaria that 's worth the wait! Shawna (sorry if i misspelled your name) was our waitress, and she made my family 's dining experience wonderful. As a retired restaurant/bar owner from the island, Shawna and the entire staff make sure your visit is a truly enjoyable (and tasty) experience. Thanks again Shawna, because you and the crew are doing an outstanding job! Locals take care of locals is an old Lowcountry saying, and the staff treats everyone who dines here as if they were local......even if they 're not, and don 't tip properly! An unfortunate tourist occurrence. Learn to tip properly, because if not....... just continue driving up the coast to Myrtle Beach. You 'll fit right in! ??

We love NYCP. It’s been our favorite since we lived here in 2016. And, we love it crispy and they always get that right. The Sicilian pie , sausage and pepperoni are our faves!Food: 5/5

One of the worst dining experiences me and my family have ever had . Over priced, our server was miserable , barely smiled. The food was mediocre at best. The house salad was pitiful and the pizza was flimsy despite me personally asking the pizza cook to make it more crispy. The only good thing was the mozzarella cheese sticks because let’s face it hard to screw that up. The real kicker to the whole experience was my younger son was out of water and took it upon himself to get his own refill of water to which the other waitress ignored. He then by accident proceeded to dump his old water in their ice bin and she just walked by. No offer to help…..so I just walked up and paid. To say I’m disappointed and underwhelmed is an understatement. I will never eat their again and I will tell everyone I know to not frequent this establishment!!!

This restaurant's design is elegant and classy, which adds to the overall experience. The food was excellent, and I would strongly recommend it to anyone looking for a memorable dining experience. Overall, I had a great time and would return in a heartbeat for more of their delicious food!