Mikey D's Pizzeria - Black River

I had just relocated to Fort Drum and was on the lookout for a great local pizza place. Mikey D's came up in my search, so I decided to give it a shot. I had a unique request for my order: half regular pizza and half cheese, with just cheese (since my kids aren't fans of pizza sauce). To my surprise, my kids devoured their pizza, which is remarkable because they usually leave food on their plates. The pizza was delicious and reasonably priced. I will definitely be back!

Mikey D's pizza and wings are among the best we've ever tasted! The white BBQ wings are incredible, and the pizza stays delicious even after being reheated for days. We even invited some friends from Buffalo to "judge" the wings, and Mikey D's came out on top! The staff is friendly and very accommodating as well!

This is hands down the best pizza and wings in Watertown and Carthage—definitely a 10 out of 10! I highly recommend it. The restaurant's interior is clean and well-maintained, and the staff clearly knows what they're doing when it comes to both the ambiance and the food. I wish more people would discover this place, as they truly deserve more recognition for their outstanding service!

I ordered a large pepperoni pizza that was incredible, but I didn't get a chance to take a photo because we finished it so quickly. The boneless wings were also fantastic—absolutely on fire!

Every visit is absolutely delicious! I appreciate the consistent quality and outstanding customer service. It’s a hidden gem in Black River, just 5 minutes from the Belvedere Gate at Fort Drum!