Slice Of Italy - Benton Park

This place holds a dear place in my first date heart with my dude. However, they didn’t pay attention to the order so it was all wrong, the broccoli on the pizza was burnt I spent way to much time digging mushrooms out of my hubby’s side of his pizza so that he could eat. I love mushrooms while he gags on the things. The waitress noticed all my hard work at picking off the topping on his first slice said absolutely nothing. We always order the same exact dish from our first date on our anniversary made the same exact way. Kinda put a damper on the evening and soggier the memory.

Maybe it's my own fault because I swore I'd never go back to this place after numerous bad experiences (mostly with service for pick up not food. I loved their chicken parm sandwich when it was good) Yet for some reason, a year and a half later, I came back and gave it another shot. Never should have. Ordered food and told it would be ready between 710 and 730. Put on the order for one chicken parm with peppers and one without. Got there at 730 and was told it would be out in 3 minutes. Took 18 minutes. Was told it was because the fries took longer than expected. Both came with peppers and was one of the worst quality meals I've ever had... fast food included. Soggy fries, soggy sandwich. A year and a half ago I was offered a gift card to make up for the poor service and I declined it and chose to delete the post and simply told the owner I would not be back (she was very nice and apologetic) and for some stupid reason I came back and here I am reviewing this place again. Hopefully some of you can learn from the mistakes that I did not. Don't order take out from here! Maybe and hopefully the service and food quality is better when you dine in

This place is one of our favorites! They have great food, and the quality of their food is always consistent- whether dine in or for delivery. As a resident of the neighborhood, we are grateful for such a great place to bring the family to eat. The service is always great. We were there last night and watched the waitress handle herself with grace and ease during a busy dinner shift. It feels like every single employee goes out of their way to make your experience with them an enjoyable one. Highly recommend!

I made a mistake of trying the buffet. The worst buffet I've ever had in my life. $20 for dried food. I should have looked at it first I absolutely do not recommend

Buffet was sad, messy, and not good. It used to be good.