Sgt. Pepperoni​ 's - BAYFIELD

This is some of the best pizza I have had. Wow we are definitely ordering gain.

Tiny place, a little strange but the pizza was great. Got a pep and sausage jumbo for 4. Seemed like a lot at first but after a few drinks this pizza was just as awesome the second time around. Awesome flavor. Only thing that would be cooler is if they had garlic bread or bread sticks or something.

Stopped here in Sept 2023, the place itself is carry out or delivery, BUT you can go next door to Greunke's Inn and order their pizza for dine in. I loved the word play with the Beatles SGT. Pepper, so we had to try it. Was not disappointed

Ordered takeout pizza from here and it was wonderful. Hot and fresh and good prices too. Very tasty thin crust! Vegetarian options: Many veggie friendly pizza toppings!

Really good tavern style pizza here! Really tasty chewy crust. We got the works! Highly recommend.