Captain Bill's - Bay Shore

Stunning views and delicious food! This restaurant boasts a fantastic location, making it an ideal spot to bring guests. We savored several fish dishes during our visit and we will certainly be back.

Absolutely fantastic! Captain Bill's is a stunning restaurant with gorgeous decor and an amazing view of the waterfront. The seafood is top-notch, and the service is both friendly and professional. I've been coming here for many years, and each visit just keeps getting better and better.

This restaurant strikes a perfect balance between elegance and a down-to-earth atmosphere. The food was excellent.

The appetizers tasted great. The spinach dip had almost a buttery consistency that went well with the crostini.

Portions were small, and the value was okay for the price. You pay more for the ambiance and the fine dining experience. But the seafood wasn't bad, and we enjoyed a good time as a group since it had a nice setting. For this reason (the view and fine dining experience), we would return. Not necessarily for the food, there are better places we know. The staff and hosts were great.