Barnegat Bay Ice Cream

Piña Colada Milkshake with pina colada italian ice and coconut icecream. Twist (chocolate/vanilla) Soft Serve Sundae with rainbow sprinkles and cookie dough bites on the side.

We love Barnegat Bay when we go there in person! This is the second time ive done delivery and the milkshakes come super thin/liquidy. They end up sitting while waiting for the driver. They should make them a little thicker for a pickup order!

Everything was great, as always. As I stated in previous reviews, I order at least two days a week. Always consistent and very good. Best ice cream place around. water ice is awesome.

I order from here at least 2 to 3 times a week. The Soft serve sundaes are awesome, chocolate covered bananas are also awesome. The Brownie overboard is awesome. This is for the chocolate lover.

Every time I order, its always great as always.