Cottage Inn Pizza Bay City

Ordered a large 3 topping pizza for takeout. Pepperoni, Banana Peppers and FRESH Mushrooms. We were very pleased! The crust was great bc often takeout pizza from anywhere can get chewy once you get it home but NO, it was the PERFECT ‘’chew.’ There was a good amount of cheese and a nice sauce… The young gal/cashier was friendly too…Thank you! We’ll have to try other things on menu in addition to pizza next time.

Great people. Service was amazing. Everything tasted great.

If I could give the food a negative 1 star, I would. This pizza made the entire family sick the morning after we had it for dinner. The only thing we choked up was this pizza that had sat overnight in our stomachs. Tasted horrible, even the dogs didn’t want our crust or leftover toppings. I can’t believe this place is even in business. Tried it a year ago too somehow they managed to make it worse.Staff were nice though.

I ordered a make your own pizza and an order of breadsticks online for pickup. My pizza was exactly as ordered and delicious! The crust was super tasty and the breadsticks were buttery with a great garlic tang. I will definitely be getting ALL of my pizza from here in the future!

Was enjoying my pizza until I took a bite and there was a black hair (I have light brown hair)…I could have puked! Pizza wasn’t very good either…just tasted cheap and made my fiancée and I sick to our stomach after eating