Sal's Pizzeria - Baldwinsville

Pizza is a 6.8 on the Portanoy scale. Very good service and other food is also great. Crust must be thinner and take some of the sweet from the sauce. Could be a solid 7.4 if they tightened the game on pizza. Just my two cents. Love of the place

This weekend I ordered 3 sheets of pizzas for my daughter's birthday party. I don't lie leaf pizza is usually my last choice because it's almost always terrible. I'll tell you this pizza was a hit. The people at the party with the same opinion as mine on were called and excited about it. The crust was homemade and not too thick at all sauce was on point and it was perfectly cooked. Thank you. Sals for an affordable and delicious meal for my guests. We will definitely use you again.

Party of 10 with reservation on a Friday night. 3 pizzas, 2 different chicken wings (chargrilled crispy), knots, flower wings and a pasta dish. Valerie was our great server and she never missed a beat. Ask her. Food was great, service even better.

The food was very good, but the service was terrible. I'm sure it was just our server because the table had really good service next to us. My son's pizza was served at room temperature as if she had been sitting for a while. The pizzas came out every 15 minutes before the pasta dishes. This is really frustrating when only half the table had food. Then we had to wait 15 minutes to get boxes. I saw our server waiting for other tables after she said she would bring our boxes. The table next to us asked for boxes and their server immediately brought them with boxes. We waited and waited. I wish I had left a smaller tip to show the server that we were unhappy, but we were automatically charged 18% of non-remuneration.

Took hour and thirty five minutes to get out order...50 bucks (for 2 meals) later for a steak sub so hard the bread won't bend (and it wasnt toasted just stale) and no mushrooms when asked for extra and greasy soaked crinkle cut frozen fries. This is the 2nd time I have had this experience..wont be ordering again.