Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - Atlantic Beach

I have been ordering pies from Pie Heaven for May birthdays for the past four years. One of the pies I always get is the gluten-free strawberry rhubarb. Unfortunately, this year when I went to pick it up on my wife's birthday, I was told that it had collapsed in the oven and the middle was caved in. I was disappointed, but the baker, Linda, was just as upset as me. She offered to make a new pie for me to pick up the next day. My wife was sad not to have her favorite pie on her birthday, but she was thrilled when I surprised her with it the following day. Even though there was a hiccup, I have always had great experiences with Pie Heaven and will continue my May pie tradition with them. They always make it right, even when they make a mistake.

We visited on a Saturday and the woman we spoke with was extremely friendly. She gave us a lot of information about the restaurant and their menu. We decided to purchase a banana cream pie and it was absolutely delicious! It tasted so fresh. I am looking forward to trying their Sheppard's pie, pot pie, and one of their boozy pies in the future. I will definitely be returning to this restaurant.

We have a friend who recently moved to Florida and whenever she visits, she brings back pies from Pie Heaven. Without a doubt, these are some of the best pies we've ever tasted. I highly suggest trying out as many flavors as possible!

OMG. The coconut custard pie is the best I’ve ever had. Not only was the pie amazing but the personalities working there are even more amazing. I’ve never been to such a friendly place. The owner does a fantastic job running that business. Every business should take lessons from her. After 9 years there It’s no wonder the business is a huge success . I highly recommend Pie Heaven. Their pie has to be the best in the country.

Just brought my mom in here and we bought a Pecan and a Key lime pie. My mom just dug into her slice of strawberry rhubarb and she said it melt in her mouth “ OMG” is what she said after the first bite. Can’t wait for supper tonight ?