Fishtale Ale House - Algoma

I really hate to even have to write this review however my late lunch experience there today was not good. We arrived at approximately 2:30 pm. We seated ourselves at the bar and were told immediately we would be the last people they would be serving today. So it felt like we were being rushed before we even had a chance to order. We were provided a list of items that were on the menu but were not available. How do you not have items for a simple BLT I ordered a burger with fried onions and roasted brussel sprouts on the side. They came back out and told me they did not have brussel sprouts even though they were on the menu. So we ordered cheese curds. The cheese curds came out and were melted but not even warm?? How this happens is beyond me. My burger came out with no onions. I asked the waitress where the onions were and she laughed and said oops the cook forgot them. It was just me and my brother and another couple eating. Could not blame the poor service on the crowd!! This was one of my favorite places to visit and eat when I was staying in Algoma. I have no idea what happened to the bar/restaurant. I will not be coming back nor would I suggest this place to anyone visiting or passing through

Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

My husband and I caught a Packer Game here on our way home from Door Co. There was one bartender/waitress and her husband, the chef, was the sole person in the kitchen; nonetheless, the food and drinks were great and the place has a nice ambiance.

2nd time here. Opened late yesterday due to being short staffed but was greeted with a smile. This was noted on facebook. Staff that was there was upfront about being short staffed, what food and beer options they did not have, which did not leave us guessing. Walleye sandwich was lightly battered and fried, soft bun, very good. Fresh walleye, still had a couple bones in it. Boneless wings not a fan, think more taste buds than anything, very saucy. Chicken with balsamic glaze/garlic sauce flatbed. Forgot the balsamic glaze but they fixed it by giving us some on the side, very good as well.

Good food, reasonable prices. I had the fish and chips and they were good. Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4