Caribbean Pie Company - Sarasota

Tart Taster

A tart taster is a great way to enjoy many of our delicious varieties. Each sampler has one key lime, chocolate silk, banana cream or salted caramel, tropical key lime and coconut tart included. You can decide which is your favorite and follow with a whol

Banana Cream With Salted Caramel

This banana cream with salted caramel is just as mouth-watering as its name. You will know exactly what we mean once you get your first bite of sea salt, caramel and banana all infused together. Yum!

Chocolate Swirled Key Lime Pie

Our chocolate swirl key lime is a delicious combination of tart key lime and rich dark chocolate. This is our classic key lime pie swirled with dark chocolate into the top. This is a must try.

Pomarańczowy Sennik

An old-time taste that may bring back memories. The orange creamsicle is reminiscent of the ice cream and popsicle combination of yesteryear. The tart orange taste is perfectly balanced with a creamy smooth taste.

Raspberry Key Lime Pie

A tasty variation of our award-winning key lime pie. Key lime pie is swirled with a rich raspberry melba sauce. This provides a little different taste, but the key lime flavor is dominant. A beautiful presentation for a delicious pie that is always a hit.