Carriage Inn Pizza - Tell City

Great place to eat when you're in Tell City. Good pizza, which was a parole here forever.

First time eating here in years. Was worth stopping in. Pizza was great. Fried pickles not as much. Service was good.

Amazing food and staff...best pizza around!! And those cupcakes are a sweet top-off too!

This is a fantastic spot for pizza lovers! Situated at the end of Main Street, the owners are incredibly friendly and serve up some excellent pizza. They specialize in thin crust, while the Post features a more traditional crust. If you prefer gluten-free options, The Carriage Inn has that covered as well. Their sauce-to-cheese ratio is just right, in contrast to the Post's very cheesy offerings, which some people do enjoy. Additionally, they have homemade desserts that are probably the best in Tell City, including special cupcakes displayed at the cashier's counter and occasionally cakes.

There's a lot to say about this place, but to sum it up: amazing food, attentive service, and a lovely setting with a cozy atmosphere. The biggest challenge is deciding what to order. The burgers are incredible, the other sandwiches are fantastic, and the pizza is simply delicious. We will definitely be returning!