The Elmton - Struthers

Broaster fried chicken was excellent. Pizza was different but good. Bar staff ignored me for about 15 minutes and when I finally talked to one of them they acted like I was making their job difficult. I had a pickup order for chicken and pizza. Nobody seemed to know where my order was. I didn't see a designated place for to go orders so I sat at the bar and tried to ask them. They didn't like that for some reason.

The Best Pizza My number pie and trust me I know my pizza

Picked up pizza and it was made wrong. Toppings were only supposed to be on 1 half of the pizza.Was told it would be 25 minutes to remake. Came back to pick up and had to pick up at the bar. The owner was behind the bar. There was a waitress wandering around. It was 15 minutes before closing. Nobody said a word to me. No hello, can I help you or anything. A customer asks about being cashedout and the owner tells them he is waiting to close but they are waiting for an order to be picked up..uh..hellloooo! So I flag down the waitress and tell her I have a remake order and she goes to get it. She hands me the box and a bag. I look at the pizza remake and it looked like they just scraped all the toppings off the one side and piled it on the other then sprinkled a few shreds of cheese on the scraped half and cooked it again. Looked like a train wreck...so not only did I have to wait 25 minutes for a sub par remake but the broasted potatoes I ordered were soggy and cold...great dinner! And not an ounce of care or even an apology to compensate for the inconvenience.

We have been going to the Elmton for close to 40 years. Best pizza around. Whenever we are in town, this is the go to pizza.

We can't get enough of their pizza or chicken.I want to try other things but always order pizza or chicken. It's so delicious.