Piccolo Pinos Pizzeria - Staten Island

When I arrived at the restaurant, I thought they were unavailable. I ordered a pepperoni and fresh garlic pizza for delivery, providing my phone number and address. I heard a knock on the door and assumed it was for me, but it turned out to be for my neighbor in the same house. The delivery person left the pizza on their porch, and I did not receive a call. The pizza was poorly made - it was floppy, the dough seemed undercooked, and it was greasy. I could not taste the garlic at all. I have been ordering this pizza for over 25 years, so I was extremely disappointed with my experience.

The owners and staff are very friendly and welcoming! The pizza is top-notch and the sausage roll is fantastic! Overall, it was a perfect 10 out of 10 experience.

This restaurant serves the best New York-style pizza! You can taste the high-quality ingredients in every bite, with no greasiness or acid reflux afterwards. My personal favorite is the Caesar salad pizza!

Avoid the pizzeria on the island at all costs. I had a terrible experience dining at this restaurant. I strongly advise against visiting this establishment.

The pizza at this restaurant is good. However, I have noticed that sometimes they adjust the prices based on the customer's race. They told my friend that each topping costs $8 - is this a fair price?