Barnaby's - Niles

Came to Barnaby's to have their pizza with the crispy crust dusted with cornmeal and wasn't disappointed. The pizza tasted just like I remembered! Yummy! The cashier was not only friendly but funny.. Talked to my husband and I like we were well known patrons. The bartender was pleasant and even asked us if our pizza was good!Reasonable prices. The only negative was the man who brought our pizza needed a fresh shirt. Came back last night and enjoyed the crispy crust and cheesy pizza. Place was super crowded there was 2 kids parties going on and everyone was having a great time! Staff were hustling to take care of everyone. Will be back soon to enjoy the pizza!

Pizza is consistently good! Ambiance consists of dark wood tables, like a traditional ole pub. Service includes counter order and pick up. One minor annoyance is the PA speaker system us extremely loud and it's used to announce every pizza and side order when ready for counter pickup. This is a great place to check out!

Barnaby’s is a pizza staple in our neighborhood. Consistent, high quality, flavorful pizza. Nice people working there. Very affordable. I never get tired of the twisted crust either… and as a bonus, who doesn’t like cold pizza the next day. Barnaby’s and one other place hit my Top 2 list of the best hot AND cold pizza. Come and enjoy their pizza and have a beer on me (kidding). I don’t even know you!

Just went for my first time this weekend. Walk towards the back to order. Food and beer registers are separate. Super family friendly low key tavern style pizza place.

One of my favorite pizzas in town. It's a very different thin crust, almost like a cracker, super crispy. The sauce is a little on the sweeter side, but still full of spices, and they put plenty of toppings on. I started going to this Barnaby's in the mid 90's, and I think there was an older lady named Carole who owned it. I can't imagine she's still around, but whoever took it over, kept the high standards she had and it shows. Don't let is 1970's Bavarian style fool you, it is a most excellent pizza!