Uncle Matty's Eatery - New Windsor

Friends and I came here after walking around a nearby historical site. So glad we did! Super friendly informative front person who equipped, I 'm just the outer face Uncle Matty stays in the kitchen. Excellent sandwiches panini; we all shared bites. Comfortable booth great service. Street parking could be scarce on other than just after lunchtime on a Friday.

We are very fortunate to have this gem in New Windsor. The service is always welcoming and attentive . The curated beer selection never disappoints and we loved our selections this evening. Our food was delicious and no one left hungry. Definitely a hometown favorite.

Holy burgers! My neighbor recommended this place. Told me it’s the best burger around and he was right. Highly recommended

I went here today with a party of 8 people. A loud bunch of friends I had not seen in years. Our service was excellent and every person complimented the food. 5 star review well deserved. Glad I recommended it!

Had another great meal Uncle Matty’s Eatery again the other day. Hubs had his usual favorite, chicken wings margarita. I branched out tried the turkey bacon ranch panini bitter blood orange sour. Both were outstanding! The panini had nice thick slices of real turkey breast (not deli meat turkey . Since I couldn’t stop eating their always yummy house made potato chips I ended up with 1/2 leftover sandwich that was delicious the next day. Only wished I’d had another sour to go along with;