Gus's Tavern - New Windsor

We lived in Newburgh, NY and visited friends who traveled from Italy and Pennsylvania. Thursday night we went as a group. Most of our group ordered the two lobstertail special. Very recommended. Delicious. Everything was perfect. If we were back in Newburgh, NY, we would definitely go back to Gus's Tavern!

Gus's is my favorite restaurant!!! The food is always great and made just to perfection. Above everything else the Staff is considerate caring and polite. Debbie is the greatest. She is on top of things and always had s great sense of humor. I would highly recommend it!!!! Sue Mistretta

I highly recommend it to anyone. It's affordable, comfortable atmosphere, nice size portions. Family owned for generations.

Tonight was our first time there and we loved it! Great food and great staff! Variety of food options for my entire family was a plus. We will definitely go again.

The food was great and the service outstanding. The schnitzel Holstein is always perfect and the beer is fresh and cold.