Colandrea's Pizza King - Middletown

I absolutely adore their pizza! Even though I left the area 40 years ago, the first thing I do when I return to visit family is order a Colandrea veggie pizza. This time, I tried a half veggie and half chicken parm, and it was incredible. The crust is perfectly chewy, and the sauce is bursting with flavor. Living in the South, I can’t find pizza like this anywhere down there. Plus, it was ready in just 15 minutes! This is truly the best pizza in the area!

I was in town for business and ordered their wings. Their mild wing sauce is the best I've ever had. I just wish I didn't live five hours away!

My wife and I visited Colandrias Pizza today. I had pre-ordered a half tray of meatballs to take home, which was a great deal at just $35 and came with garlic bread and three small loaves. We started with a slice of Grandma pizza as an appetizer, and it was absolutely incredible. For our main course, we had a seafood combo with Fra Diavolo sauce over linguine, which included garlic bread and a side salad, all for $21.99. It was delicious, and we couldn't finish it! I highly recommend Colandrias Pizza.

The rumors are unfounded! We were initially reluctant to eat here after hearing about the change in ownership and wondering if the pizza would taste different. Fortunately, that is not the case. I grew up enjoying Colandrea's pizza, and it has always been my favorite. I'm thrilled to report that the pizza tastes just as we remember—delicious as always! I highly recommend giving the new owners a chance; they won’t let you down.

This was my first time ordering food after moving to the area, and I have to say, this pizza was fantastic. The crust had a perfect texture, and the toppings—clearly, someone put a lot of care into them. They didn't hold back at all, and I must say, the pizza looked absolutely amazing. I've definitely found my new favorite pizza place! It looked so delicious that I completely forgot to take a picture before diving in.