Catskill Bagel Company - Brooklyn

I don’t understand the low reviews. It is by no means the best bagel in Brooklyn, but it is damn solid and also good vibes in there and LOVELY people working there. I think my biggest thing to get to 5 stars would he to get the bagels a little larger and put a little more cream cheese on them. Also for the everything bagels for gods sake put more everything goodness all around it and not just a little on top. Even despite these criticisms it’s a solid local option and I love taking visitors there, but it’s not ready to compete with the best of the best yet.

I love this bagel deli. I always enjoy the bagels, the fresh juices and the deli sandwiches. It’s really cute and has a lovely atmosphere.

Surprised at the low reviews on here. This is my go-to bagel spot in the area; the bagels are fluffy, yeasty, soft deliciousness, and I’ve never had an issue with too little cream cheese. The staff haven’t been rude to me, though they are a bit disorganized at times. I’ll take it for the bagel quality.

My favorite bagels in this area. I always do a pickup order online, so haven't had the same issues as others with rude service. My order is always ready, correct and tasty. They do get very busy though so it can take a bit to get my order but I just plan that in before I go pick up.

The actual bagel was ok. I keep it simple: Everything bagel with cream cheese. But the service, the attitude, and the nerve of the staff to be so rude and roll eyes on customers…. Oh no ma’am, I won’t be coming back here.