Broadway Diner - Baraboo

I am in love with this place! If I lived anywhere nearby this would be my spot where the waitresses knew my name and order. Yummy yummy patty melt. Delicious burger and amazing fries. Didn’t order the cinnamon rolls but the table next to us did and I legit drooled. Waitress was fast and attentive. Cooks behind the counter did and awesome job and were so fun to watch!!!

We came here for brunch and got some of your basic breakfast foods like eggs and hash browns that were super good! The service was pretty quick for how busy it was. Our waitress was very nice and hard working. The oldies music playing definitely added to the oldies diner atmosphere. And thank you to the kind gentleman who paid for our breakfast! It really made our day. This diner was such a nice experience.

The biscuits and gravy were unbelievably delicious! Service was so quick and kind. 100% coming back!

Corned beef hash is homemade (not from a can) and delicious every time. Their toast is also a must

Worst experience I have had in a long time. The waitress was rude and the manager wasn’t much better. I ordered the cheddar biscuits and they came with no cheese on them. I asked the waitress if it was supposed to have cheese , she said yes it’s baked on top of the biscuit. I said I don’t see any cheese on here do you she said no I don’t I said OK but is it supposed to have cheese? She said yes it is and she just kept arguing with me that oh well, there’s nothing she can do so my daughter said can you just get her some cheese, the waitress bought me cheese and then charged me a dollar for the cheese . I took a pic so that I could show that there was no cheese on it when I went to pay the bill I said I don’t feel like I should have to pay for the cheese when it was supposed to come with it . so I asked for the manager the manager asked the waitress did it have cheese on it and she said yes it did. She scraped it off. I said no I didn’t. I said you’re literally standing here lying and she said no I watched you. I can’t even pull up camera footage. I said go ahead pull up the camera footage. I said I took a picture to show you, which the manager said she didn’t want to see the pic and then about eight of them stood there arguing with me over a dollar. there’s a right way in a wrong way to deal with customers and a very bad experience would have been fine if they would’ve done their job disappointed not going back. Haven’t been there in six years because of a bad experience before obviously it hasn’t gotten any better .