Amagansett Seafood Store

Mikes seafood is unparalleled. I may never have had a better lobster roll. And the ceviche and smoked bass are gourmet! Perhaps most of all, Mike is fun, charming and generous!

Rude ! No regard for the costumer! Refused to help ! Might have been intoxicated?

I went in right before closing on a holiday weekend and it was quite a scene. The owner was hugging regulars like they were family. Then he excused himself to turn up the stereo when a good Van Morrison song came on. A young man helped me with my order and explained it had been a hectic day. He thanked me for being flexible and gave me some complimentary Mahi Mahi. We had a feast with the great fish and plan to come back.

Mike is special, he knows everything about fish and by choosing Chelsea, nothing about football. Love this guy and the shop. Hidden treasure is salmon curry.

Tried this place for the first time a few months ago and when I went back to the area, I had to go back. It is hands down the best lobster roll in the world. So much lobster meat!